This site is intended for health professionals only

Proposal to mandate more GP roles on ICBs backed by BMA


By Costanza Potter
13 January 2022

Share this story:


The BMA has backed a proposed amendment to the Health and Care Bill that would see more GP roles mandated on ICS boards.

It has also called for ‘formalised roles’ for LMCs ‘at every level of ICSs’.

It comes as the Bill yesterday moved from its second reading into the committee stage at the House of Lords, during which amendments will be debated and voted on.

In a Parliamentary briefing for peers, published last week, the BMA said it is ‘calling for amendments to the Bill that would strengthen minimum membership of Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) to include more than one GP and a clinical representative from secondary care.’

It said this comes as the Bill ‘as written risks undercutting local clinical engagement and leadership’ by losing ‘positive elements’ of CCGs, such as their ‘accountability to clinicians and patients as a body of elected local GPs’.

The document added that the BMA supports an amendment that would ‘ensure that primary care professions have mandated roles within Integrated Care Partnerships with a member appointed by each of the practitioner committees’, including LMCs.

It also supports amendments that would require the ICB, partner trusts and NHS Foundation Trusts to ‘consult the relevant primary care Local Representative Committees’ – such as LMCs – when publishing their annual ‘forward plan’, it said.

The briefing document added: ‘The BMA calls on peers to amend the Bill to ensure independent clinical leadership from across primary, secondary and public health care is embedded at every level of ICSs, including formalised roles for Local Medical Committees (LMCs) and Local Negotiating Committees (LNCs).’

It said: ‘The Bill sets out core minimum membership of Integrated Care Boards (ICBs), which includes at least one member nominated by GPs and primary care, a member nominated by NHS or Foundation Trusts, and a member nominated by local authority representatives. 

‘The BMA is concerned that this provision, and further detail set out in the NHSE ICS design framework, falls far short of ensuring clinical leadership and representation needed. ICSs are currently finalising their draft constitutions, including the proposed membership of their ICBs, with many failing to provide adequate representation for clinicians. ‘

It added: ‘The BMA is concerned the Bill risks undercutting truly representative clinical leadership by failing to retain some of the positive elements of Clinical Commissioning Groups. 

‘This includes their vital function in ensuring accountability to clinicians and patients as a body of elected, local GPs.’

Integrated care boards are due to be discussed tomorrow, according to a provisional schedule published today.

In June, NHS England guidance revealed that just one GP would be required to be appointed to ICS boards, which are set to replace CCGs as commissioners of health services.

GPs had previously warned that more must be done to prevent ‘tokenistic’ GP representation on ICSs, amid ongoing concerns.

The BMA council passed a resolution calling for MPs to reject the new Health and Care Bill in July, arguing it is ‘not the right time’ to be bringing in widespread legal reforms while the NHS deals with the Covid-19 pandemic.

This story first appeared on our sister title, Pulse.

Want news like this straight to your inbox?

Related news

David Olusoga: Racism ‘still disfiguring’ the NHS
Racism and discrimination are ‘still disfiguring’ the NHS and limited opportunities are available to staff...
Sajid Javid NHS
Health secretary Sajid Javid says the current primary care model is ‘not working’
Health secretary Sajid Javid set out a ‘plan for change’ for primary care, as the...