This site is intended for health professionals only

Care Bill ‘robs Peter to pay Paul’

21 May 2013

Share this story:

New government reforms alone will not solve the challenge of funding social care, according to a new report published by health thinktank The King’s Fund. 

New government reforms alone will not solve the challenge of funding social care, according to a new report published by health thinktank The King’s Fund. 

The government’s Care Bill, before parliament for the first time today, would introduce a cap on the amount individuals contribute towards the cost of their care, a central recommendation of the Dilnot Commission in 2011. 
But Paying for social care: Beyond Dilnot argues that, while this will provide welcome protection for people from the costs associated with long stays in residential care more should be done to meet mounting financial pressures.
The report has called for a stronger focus on the challenge of eligibility and ensuring that more people are able to access the right level of support. 
It also raises concerns that unmet need, and its impact on carers, will place further pressure on an NHS “already under significant strain”, arguing that it is time to look at how to secure enough resources to meet current and future needs.
Richard Humphries, assistant director of policy at The King’s Fund, said: “The government’s reforms are an important milestone – but there is much more to be done. There needs to be an informed debate so that people understand how they benefit from the changes, and to address the difficult long-term choices that remain about how much we spend on care, and how to fund this.
"We must also think boldly about removing the unhelpful fault lines which exist across health and social care spending. Instead of ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul’ by raiding the NHS budget to bail out social care, we need a more ambitious shift towards single-budget settlements for NHS and social care."
The report identifies four main priority areas, which build on the foundations of Dilnot to provide a new roadmap for social care reform.
  • The government should ensure proper preparation and planning for implementing the Dilnot proposals, to establish a new framework for planning and cost-sharing.
  • The 2015/16 Spending Review should be used to move towards a single strategic budget settlement for the NHS and adult social care, and closer alignment of local authority and clinical commissioning group (CCG) budgets around individual needs.
  • Health and wellbeing boards have a crucial leadership role to play in ensuring care reform is part of a wider transformation of local health and care services.
  • There should be a fresh debate about the options for funding the quantity and quality of care needed in future, and how to overcome dividing lines between the ways health and social care are paid for.

Want news like this straight to your inbox?

Related news

Health, doctor doing work, health inequalities,
Tackling health inequalities through Core20PLUS5
Seven months on from the launch of Core20PLUS5, some primary care leaders have begun to...
Racism against NHS staff more common from managers than public
Racism against Black and ethnic minority NHS leaders was more commonly perpetrated by managers within...